Can You Do Five-Factor Investing With ETFs?

Replicating the Fama-French five-factor model with 4-5 liquid ETFs

By John T · Updated August 29, 2026

Quick answer: Yes. The Fama-French five-factor model covers market, size, value, profitability, and investment. A retail investor can approximate all five with 4-5 ETFs: VTI (market + small-cap exposure), AVUV or DFSV (concentrated size + value + profitability loading), COWZ (captures the investment factor via high free-cash-flow yield), and QUAL or DGRO (additional profitability/quality tilt). A 60/20/10/10 blend costs about 0.12% blended and loads positively on all five Fama-French factors in regressions.

This page is a deeper dive into the "Fama-French Five-Factor Model" section of our factor investing guide. If you want to go beyond three factors and actually implement the 2015 update with ETFs, read on.

Quick Refresher: The Fama-French Five Factors

  1. Market (Mkt-RF): excess return of the broad stock market over the risk-free rate.
  2. Size (SMB, Small Minus Big): premium of small-cap stocks over large-cap.
  3. Value (HML, High Minus Low): premium of high book-to-market over low.
  4. Profitability (RMW, Robust Minus Weak): premium of high-profitability firms.
  5. Investment (CMA, Conservative Minus Aggressive): premium of firms with low asset growth (conservative capital allocation).

Fama and French introduced profitability and investment in their 2015 paper to explain anomalies the 3-factor model missed.

The 5-ETF Portfolio That Covers All Five Factors

ETFWeightExpenseFactors Captured
VTI (Total US Market)60%0.03%Market + some size
AVUV (US Small-Cap Value)15%0.25%Size + Value + Profitability (integrated)
COWZ (US Cash Flow Kings)10%0.49%Investment (low-investment, high-FCF)
QUAL (MSCI USA Quality)10%0.15%Profitability
AVDV (Intl Small-Cap Value)5%0.36%Size + Value (international diversification)

Blended expense ratio: ~0.12%. Based on publicly disclosed methodology documents as of 2026.

Factor-by-Factor Implementation Notes

1. Market

VTI, VOO, or SPTM all work. VTI is the default because it includes small and mid-caps, which gives you a small size factor loading for free.

2. Size

Pure size ETFs (VB, IJR) exist but deliver weak factor loading alone because the post-1980 size premium is small. Better to get size through a joint small-value ETF like AVUV, where size interacts with value to produce the historically strong small-cap value premium.

3. Value

VLUE, IUSV, and VTV are the broad-market options. AVUV gives deeper value loading in the small-cap space, which is where value has historically paid best.

4. Profitability (RMW)

QUAL (MSCI) and SPHQ (Invesco) both screen on ROE and earnings quality, which correlate with Fama-French profitability. Avantis and Dimensional funds build profitability into their core multi-factor screens. DGRO captures it indirectly via sustained dividend growth.

5. Investment (CMA)

The hardest factor to buy cleanly. COWZ (Pacer Cash Cows 100) and CALF (Pacer Small Cap Cash Cows) screen for high free-cash-flow yield, which correlates strongly with the "conservative investment" factor. MOAT (VanEck) picks stocks with wide economic moats, which tend to score well on CMA.

Simpler Alternative: One Integrated ETF

If 5 ETFs is too many, use a single integrated fund that already targets all factors in one package:

  • AVGE (Avantis All Equity Markets ETF) - global equity with tilts on size, value, profitability, 0.23%
  • DFAC (DFA US Core Equity 2) - US integrated value + profitability + size, 0.17%
  • AVUS (Avantis US Equity) - US multi-factor core, 0.15%

These give you 60-80% of what the 5-ETF portfolio captures, with one ticker and no rebalancing between sleeves.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is five-factor better than three-factor?

Statistically, the 2015 five-factor model explains more of the cross-section of returns than the 1993 three-factor model - particularly for profitable, conservative-investment firms. Practically, the improvement for a retail portfolio is modest because size and profitability often overlap in small-cap value funds.

Which ETF best captures the investment (CMA) factor?

COWZ is the most commonly cited. It selects the 100 highest free-cash-flow-yield companies in the Russell 1000, which closely tracks the "conservative investment" side of CMA. MOAT and DGRO are reasonable substitutes.

Can I do five-factor investing with Vanguard ETFs only?

Not cleanly. Vanguard has strong coverage for market (VTI), value (VTV), and quality-like growth (VUG), but does not offer a retail investment-factor or RMW-focused ETF. You will need to mix iShares or Avantis funds to cover all five factors.

Should momentum or low volatility be included?

They are not part of Fama-French's five-factor model - that model predates momentum formally. If you want a "complete" factor portfolio, add MTUM (momentum) and USMV (low volatility) as separate 5% sleeves. But stay disciplined: above 6 factors, complexity starts to cost more than the extra diversification buys.

Related Reading