Real Estate vs. Stocks Calculator
Side-by-side comparison: buying a home vs. renting and investing. Accounts for appreciation, mortgage interest, taxes, maintenance, and opportunity cost.
By Mark T ยท Updated August 29, 2026
๐ Home Purchase
๐ Rent + Invest Scenario
Wealth Comparison Over Time
Year-by-Year Detail
Home equity vs. after-tax stock portfolio net wealth, plus annual ownership and rental costs.
| Year | Home Value | Equity | Own Cost/yr | Portfolio (gross) | Net After Tax | Rent/yr | ฮ (Home โ Stocks) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $466k | $110k | $40k | $111k | $110k | $26k | -$297 |
| 2 | $482k | $130k | $40k | $133k | $131k | $27k | -$842 |
| 3 | $499k | $151k | $40k | $157k | $153k | $28k | -$2k |
| 4 | $516k | $173k | $41k | $182k | $176k | $29k | -$3k |
| 5 | $534k | $196k | $41k | $209k | $201k | $30k | -$4k |
| 6 | $553k | $220k | $42k | $238k | $227k | $31k | -$7k |
| 7 | $573k | $245k | $42k | $269k | $255k | $32k | -$9k |
| 8 | $593k | $272k | $42k | $302k | $284k | $32k | -$12k |
| 9 | $613k | $299k | $43k | $337k | $315k | $33k | -$16k |
| 10 | $635k | $327k | $43k | $374k | $348k | $34k | -$21k |
What Drives the Outcome
Real Estate vs. Stocks: The Full Picture
The "rent vs. buy" decision is one of the most important financial choices most people make - and one of the most misunderstood. The conventional wisdom that "renting is throwing money away" ignores the opportunity cost of the down payment, the hidden costs of homeownership, and the fact that stock market returns have historically matched or exceeded real estate returns without the illiquidity, leverage risk, and maintenance burden.
This calculator compares the two scenarios on equal financial footing. In the buy scenario, you purchase a home and sell it after the analysis period, netting the equity minus selling costs and capital gains tax. In the rent and invest scenario, you rent an equivalent property, invest the down payment in a diversified index fund portfolio, and invest any month-to-month cost difference (if owning costs more than renting, that excess is invested; if renting costs more, your portfolio is drawn down by that amount).
Neither answer is always right. Real estate wins when home appreciation is high, the mortgage rate is low relative to stock returns, or the rent is much cheaper than the ownership cost (leaving little to invest). Stocks win when the down payment would compound significantly, rents are cheap relative to ownership costs, or the holding period is short (avoiding 6โ8% selling costs).
The biggest swing factors: home appreciation rate (highly variable by market), mortgage rate vs. stock return spread, how long you hold, and the rent-to-own cost ratio in your specific market. Use the sliders to find your breakeven assumptions. For those building wealth toward financial independence, the opportunity cost of a large down payment tied up in real estate is especially worth modeling - a diversified stock portfolio invested over the same period can often close the gap when appreciation is modest.
Frequently Asked Questions
Assumptions: 30-year fixed mortgage; 6% total selling costs at end of holding period; mortgage interest deduction at your marginal tax rate (actual deductibility depends on itemizing); $250k capital gains exclusion applied to home sale. Stock returns are nominal pre-tax. This tool is for educational purposes only - consult a financial advisor before making major decisions.
How This Tool Works
Calculation steps
- Enter your inputs using the fields and sliders on this page.
- Calculations run instantly in your browser - no data is sent to a server.
- Results update in real time as you change inputs.
Assumptions
- Projections use the formulas documented on this page and assume constant inputs unless noted.
- Returns, tax rates, and inflation are simplified for educational purposes.
Limitations
- This tool provides estimates for educational purposes only, not personalized financial advice.
- Actual results will differ due to market volatility, taxes, fees, and changing personal circumstances.