The Two Indexes Explained
Before comparing performance, you need to understand what you're actually buying when you invest in either fund. These are two different indexes tracking two different slices of the US stock market - though with enormous overlap.
The key distinction: the S&P 500 is a curated list of large companies, while the total market fund is a comprehensive index of virtually every US company. In theory, this sounds like a meaningful difference. In practice, the story gets complicated fast.
The Overlap Is Enormous - 80% Correlation
Here's the number that surprises most investors: the 500 companies in the S&P 500 account for approximately 83% of the weight of a total US market fund like VTI. In other words, when you buy a total market fund, you're essentially buying the S&P 500 - plus a small allocation to smaller companies.
Breaking down VTI's approximate composition by market cap segment:
- Large-cap (S&P 500 overlap): ~83% of fund weight
- Mid-cap stocks: ~12% of fund weight
- Small-cap stocks: ~4% of fund weight
- Micro-cap stocks: ~1% of fund weight
The rolling 12-month correlation between VTI and VOO typically sits at 0.998 to 0.999 - essentially perfect. On any given day, week, month, or year, these two funds move nearly identically. If the market is up 10%, both will be up approximately 10%.
The "extra" 3,000+ companies in a total market fund are tiny relative to mega-caps. Apple alone - a single company - has a market cap larger than the combined weight of the bottom 2,000 stocks in a total market fund. Size matters enormously in market-cap weighting.
Historical Performance: Essentially a Tie
Let's look at actual returns. Comparing VTI (Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF) vs VOO (Vanguard S&P 500 ETF) - both launched by Vanguard, virtually identical expense ratios, the fairest possible comparison:
- 1-year: VTI ~23.8% vs VOO ~25.0% (VOO leads by ~1.2%)
- 5-year: VTI ~14.0% vs VOO ~14.5% (VOO leads by ~0.5%)
- 10-year: VTI ~12.9% vs VOO ~13.0% (essentially tied, within 0.1%)
- Since VTI inception (2001): VTI ~8.4% vs VOO ~8.3% (VTI leads marginally)
The pattern is clear: over long periods, the two funds perform within a rounding error of each other. Over shorter recent periods (particularly 2010โ2023), the S&P 500 has had a slight edge, because large-cap growth stocks dominated. During periods when small caps shine - such as 2000โ2010 - the total market fund leads.
Similarly, VTSAX (Vanguard Total Stock Market Admiral) vs VFIAX (Vanguard 500 Index Admiral) tell the same story. Both carry a 0.04% expense ratio. Over the past two decades, returns have been within 0.2% annualized in either direction, depending on the time period measured.
The honest conclusion: you cannot reliably predict which will outperform over the next decade. Both are excellent choices, and the decision between them should not consume significant mental energy.
The Small-Cap Premium Argument
The academic case for the total market fund rests on the Fama-French three-factor model, developed by Nobel Prize winner Eugene Fama and researcher Kenneth French. Their 1992 research identified that smaller companies have historically earned higher returns than large companies over very long periods - the so-called "small-cap premium."
The logic: small companies are riskier (higher bankruptcy risk, less access to capital, less analyst coverage). Investors demand a higher expected return to compensate for that risk. Over decades, this risk premium shows up in returns.
Here's the problem: the small-cap premium is lumpy and unreliable in practice. Consider:
- 1926โ1980s: Small caps dramatically outperformed large caps, establishing the academic literature
- 2000โ2012: Small caps outperformed meaningfully, partly due to the tech bust hitting large caps harder
- 2010โ2023: The small-cap premium essentially vanished. Large-cap growth - particularly mega-cap tech - crushed small caps. The Russell 2000 significantly underperformed the S&P 500 over this period.
A total market fund gives you only a modest small-cap tilt (~5% in small caps). If you genuinely believe in the small-cap premium, a dedicated small-cap value fund (like AVUV, VBR, or IJS) would give you far more targeted exposure. The total market fund's small-cap weight is too modest to move the needle meaningfully.
Jack Bogle's Surprising Opinion
Here's where it gets interesting. Jack Bogle - the founder of Vanguard, the man who pioneered index funds and created the very first index mutual fund in 1976 - actually preferred the S&P 500 over the total market index.
"There's very little difference between the two, but I favor the S&P 500 because of its long history, its recognition, and - yes - its committee selection process provides a modest quality filter. The small-cap premium is real in theory, but I'm not sure it will persist going forward."
Bogle's reasoning was pragmatic rather than ideological:
- Historical track record: The S&P 500 index has data going back to the 1920s - a longer and more studied history than total market indexes.
- Quality filter: The S&P 500's committee selection requires companies to be profitable before inclusion. This provides a mild screen against the weakest small companies. Bogle saw this as a feature, not a bug.
- Skepticism about the small-cap premium persisting: Bogle argued that as the small-cap premium became widely known, arbitrage would erode it. If everyone piles into small caps for the premium, prices rise and expected future returns fall.
- Simplicity and recognition: The S&P 500 is universally understood, widely tracked, and available in virtually every 401(k) plan in America.
It's a notable irony: the man who built Vanguard's Total Stock Market fund preferred the S&P 500. His view wasn't that the total market was wrong - just that the practical differences don't justify a strong preference for it.
Warren Buffett's Recommendation
The world's most famous investor has been unambiguous about what ordinary investors should own. In his 2013 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders, Buffett disclosed the instructions in his will regarding the trust for his wife:
"My advice to the trustee could not be more simple: Put 10% of the cash in short-term government bonds and 90% in a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund. (I suggest Vanguard's.) I believe the trust's long-term results from this policy will be superior to those attained by most investors - whether pension funds, institutions or individuals - who employ high-fee managers."
Note what Buffett specified: the S&P 500, not a total market fund. He suggested Vanguard specifically (likely VOO or VFIAX), and paired it with 10% in short-term government bonds - not a more complex multi-fund portfolio.
Buffett's reasoning aligns with Bogle's: the S&P 500 is the simplest, most recognizable, and battle-tested vehicle for owning American business. Neither Bogle nor Buffett felt the small-cap exposure in a total market fund was a meaningful reason to prefer it.
Expense Ratios and Fund Options
One area where you don't need to overthink things: costs. Both types of funds are extraordinarily cheap, and the difference between them is negligible.
- VTI (Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF): 0.03%
- VTSAX (Vanguard Total Stock Market Admiral): 0.04%
- ITOT (iShares Core S&P Total US Stock Market): 0.03%
- SCHB (Schwab US Broad Market ETF): 0.03%
- FSKAX (Fidelity Total Market Index Fund): 0.015%
- VOO (Vanguard S&P 500 ETF): 0.03%
- VFIAX (Vanguard 500 Index Admiral): 0.04%
- IVV (iShares Core S&P 500 ETF): 0.03%
- SPLG (SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 ETF): 0.02%
- FXAIX (Fidelity 500 Index Fund): 0.015%
- SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust): 0.0945% - older and higher cost, still the most traded ETF in the world
On a $100,000 investment, the difference between a 0.03% and a 0.04% expense ratio is $10 per year. That's not worth a moment of deliberation. What matters far more is whether your 401(k) plan offers a good option in either category.
401(k) availability: The S&P 500 index fund wins here in practice. Nearly every 401(k) plan in the US offers at least one S&P 500 index fund option. Total market funds are common too, but less universally available. If your plan only offers one type, that decision is made for you.
When the Difference Might Matter
For most investors, the choice between total market and S&P 500 is genuinely inconsequential. But there are a few scenarios where it could be worth thinking about:
Very Long Time Horizons (40+ Years)
If you're 25 years old and won't touch this money until you're 70, you're maximizing the window in which a small-cap premium - if it persists - could show up. Even 0.2% annualized outperformance compounded over 45 years creates meaningful wealth. A total market fund gives you modest, automatic small-cap exposure without any extra work.
You Want More Small-Cap Exposure Deliberately
If you've read the Fama-French literature and are convinced by the small-cap value premium, a total market fund is a mild step in that direction. But for a more deliberate factor tilt, you'd be better served by adding a dedicated small-cap value ETF like AVUV (Avantis US Small Cap Value, 0.25%) or VBR (Vanguard Small Cap Value, 0.07%) alongside an S&P 500 fund rather than relying on the total market fund's limited small-cap weight.
Factor-Based Portfolio Construction
Some investors building multi-factor portfolios (value, size, profitability, momentum) prefer to start with a broader market base and overlay factor tilts rather than starting with the S&P 500's large-cap-only universe. In this context, total market is the more theoretically complete starting point.
Tax-Loss Harvesting Pairs
More sophisticated investors sometimes hold VTI and VOO in different accounts specifically because they track different indexes. This creates the opportunity to tax-loss harvest between them during market downturns without triggering wash-sale rules - a strategy primarily relevant in taxable accounts.
The Verdict: Choose and Don't Look Back
After reviewing the data - returns history, expense ratios, academic research, and the opinions of Bogle and Buffett - the honest conclusion is this: both funds are excellent, and the choice between them is among the least important investing decisions you'll ever make.
Here's how to think about it:
- Choose the Total Market (VTI/VTSAX/FSKAX) if: you want the most complete representation of US equity markets, you believe in the long-run small-cap premium, or your plan offers it at a competitive cost.
- Choose the S&P 500 (VOO/VFIAX/FXAIX) if: your 401(k) offers it as the primary option, you prefer the longest historical track record, or you're comforted knowing Bogle and Buffett both recommended it to their own families.
The total market fund is more complete in theory - it owns the entire market by design. The S&P 500 has historical prestige, universal availability, and the explicit backing of the two most influential figures in index investing. Neither choice is wrong. Once you've picked your index, see our ETF vs mutual fund comparison to choose the right fund structure.
The worst outcome is spending weeks researching this decision, building elaborate spreadsheets comparing 20-year backtests, and delaying your actual investing. The second-worst outcome is switching between the two every few years based on recent performance - which adds no value and may create unnecessary tax events.
Pick one. Set up automatic contributions. Reinvest dividends. Rebalance annually with your bond allocation. Ignore the noise. That's the entire strategy - and it will outperform the vast majority of investors who spend far more time and effort on their portfolios.
As Bogle put it: "The greatest enemy of a good plan is the dream of a perfect plan." A total market fund or an S&P 500 fund is a good plan. Start there.
Related Articles & Tools
Why Index Funds Win
92% of active managers underperform index funds over 15 years. Here's the math behind why passive investing wins.
Read ArticleHow to Pick Index Funds
A practical guide to choosing the right index funds for your portfolio - covering costs, coverage, and account type considerations.
Read ArticleThe Small-Cap Value Premium
Fama and French's research showed small-cap value stocks earn higher long-run returns. Here's the evidence - and the caveats.
Read ArticleFree Tools & Courses
Portfolio vs S&P 500
Directly backtest VTI (total market) against VOO (S&P 500) over 10 years.
Open Tool โDividend & Value Stock Screener
Explore what small and mid-cap stocks the total market fund adds beyond the S&P 500.
Open Tool โIndex Fund Fundamentals
A free course on building a low-cost index portfolio - S&P 500 or total market both covered.
Start Free โ