What Is the 4% Rule and How Does It Work?

The 4% rule is a retirement withdrawal guideline: in your first year of retirement, withdraw 4% of your total portfolio. Each year after, increase that dollar amount by the rate of inflation - not by recalculating 4% of your current balance. This page goes beyond the basic formula to cover what actually counts as your portfolio, which accounts to draw from first, how much you need to save, and how the rule has evolved since its creation in 1994.

By Mark T  ·  Updated April 14, 2026

The Short Answer

Withdraw 4% of your portfolio in Year 1. Adjust that dollar amount upward by inflation each subsequent year - regardless of whether markets are up or down. The math, formula, and worked examples are covered in the 4% Rule full guide. This page focuses on the practical side: what the rule actually requires when you sit down to implement it.

Key distinction: You do not recalculate 4% of your portfolio each year. You lock in a dollar amount at retirement and adjust it for inflation. A retiree with a $1M portfolio withdraws $40,000 in Year 1. If inflation is 3%, they withdraw $41,200 in Year 2 - even if their portfolio dropped to $850,000.

What Counts as Your Portfolio?

Not every asset goes into the 4% rule calculation. The rule applies to your investable portfolio - liquid assets you can actually draw down over time.

Asset TypeInclude in Portfolio?Notes
401(k) / 403(b)✅ YesCount the full balance; withdrawals are taxable as ordinary income
Traditional IRA✅ YesWithdrawals taxable as ordinary income; RMDs kick in at 73
Roth IRA✅ YesQualified withdrawals are tax-free - high strategic value in late retirement
Taxable brokerage account✅ YesLong-term gains taxed at capital gains rates (often 0–15%)
Primary home❌ No (usually)Include only if you plan to downsize and invest the proceeds
Social Security / pension❌ NoSubtract this income from your spending need before applying the 4% rule
Rental income❌ NoTreat as income that reduces portfolio withdrawal need

Practical example: You spend $70,000/year and receive $25,000 in Social Security. Your portfolio only needs to cover $45,000 - requiring $1,125,000 under the 4% rule, not $1,750,000. Social Security dramatically reduces the portfolio size you need.

Which Accounts to Draw From First

The 4% rule tells you how much to withdraw - but not from where. The order matters significantly for taxes and portfolio longevity.

The Standard Withdrawal Order
  1. Taxable brokerage accounts first - capital gains rates are typically lower than ordinary income tax rates. Drawing here first allows tax-advantaged accounts to keep compounding.
  2. Traditional IRA / 401(k) second - withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income. After age 73, Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) may force withdrawals anyway, so coordinating with RMD schedules matters.
  3. Roth IRA last - no RMDs, no taxes on qualified withdrawals, and contributions can be withdrawn penalty-free at any time. Preserving Roth accounts for late retirement is a powerful hedge against rising healthcare costs.
💡 Roth Conversion Window

Many early retirees exploit a tax planning opportunity: if you retire before Social Security begins and have low income, you can convert Traditional IRA funds to a Roth at a low tax rate. This fills your Roth account for later use and reduces future RMDs. The window is typically ages 60–70 when income is lowest and tax brackets are most favorable.

The 25x Rule: Your Savings Target

The 4% rule works in reverse as a retirement savings target. If you can safely withdraw 4% per year, you need a portfolio equal to 25 times your annual spending need - this is known as the 25x rule.

Annual Spending Need25x Target (4% rule)~29x Target (3.5% rate)~33x Target (3% rate)
$30,000$750,000$857,000$1,000,000
$50,000$1,250,000$1,429,000$1,667,000
$75,000$1,875,000$2,143,000$2,500,000
$100,000$2,500,000$2,857,000$3,333,000

"Annual spending need" is your total retirement spending minus guaranteed income (Social Security, pension, rental). If you need $80,000/year but collect $30,000 in Social Security, your portfolio only needs to cover $50,000 - cutting your savings target from $2M to $1.25M.

Early retirees with 40–50 year horizons should use the 3% or 3.5% column for a safer margin. See How Long Will the 4% Rule Last? for the success rate data by horizon.

The Rule Has Evolved: Bengen's 4.7% Update (2025)

William Bengen - who created the 4% rule in 1994 - published a significant update in August 2025 with his book "A Richer Retirement." His revised "Universal SAFEMAX" is 4.7%, up from his earlier 4.5% estimate and the original 4%.

The difference comes from portfolio construction. Bengen's original research used only US large-cap stocks and intermediate bonds. His updated research includes five additional asset classes: international stocks, small-cap, mid-cap, micro-cap equities, and Treasury bills. The addition of small- and micro-cap stocks - which have historically outperformed large-cap over long periods - raises the sustainable withdrawal rate.

Important context: 4.7% is a historical floor - the most conservative sustainable rate, calibrated to the worst possible retirement start dates in the data. The average SAFEMAX across all periods is around 7.1%. Most financial planners still recommend 4% as a simpler, more conservative baseline unless you are specifically building a portfolio with meaningful small- and micro-cap exposure.

For the full history of how the rule was created and validated, see Who Invented the 4% Rule?

Why Many Retirees Can Spend More: The Spending Smile

The 4% rule assumes constant inflation-adjusted spending throughout retirement. Research by Morningstar's David Blanchett shows actual retiree spending follows a different - and more forgiving - pattern called the "retirement spending smile":

  • Early retirement (60s–early 70s): Higher spending on travel, experiences, and activities
  • Mid-retirement (mid-70s–early 80s): Slower pace, real spending declines approximately 1% per year
  • Late retirement (85+): Healthcare costs rise and partially offset the earlier decline

By age 84, the average retiree spends about 26% less in inflation-adjusted terms than they did at 65. Because the 4% rule assumes you spend the same amount (inflation-adjusted) forever, it is actually more conservative than typical retiree behavior. Blanchett's research suggests that retirees with typical spending patterns, Social Security, and some flexibility could safely start withdrawals at 4.4–5.6% while maintaining a high probability of portfolio survival.

Common Misunderstandings

Misunderstanding 1: "Recalculate 4% each year"

Recalculating 4% of your portfolio's current value annually is a different strategy called constant percentage withdrawal. Your portfolio can never technically reach zero this way, but your income becomes unpredictable - potentially dropping 25–30% in a bad market year. The 4% rule provides income stability by anchoring withdrawals to inflation, not market performance.

Misunderstanding 2: "Social Security counts toward the 4%"

Social Security sits outside the 4% rule. Always subtract guaranteed income from your annual spending need before applying the rule. Skipping this step dramatically overstates how much you need to save.

Misunderstanding 3: "4% is always the right number"

The original rule was built for 30-year retirements with a standard stock/bond portfolio. Early retirees (40–50 year horizons) should use a lower rate (3–3.5%). Retirees with significant guaranteed income, spending flexibility, or small-cap exposure may safely use a higher rate. The accuracy of the 4% rule varies significantly by individual circumstances.

Related Resources