Who Came Up with the 4% Rule?
William Bengen, a California-based financial planner, developed the 4% rule in 1994. He published his landmark findings in the Journal of Financial Planning after analyzing US stock and bond returns from 1926 to 1976 - covering every market crash, recession, and boom in that half-century. His conclusion: a 4% annual inflation-adjusted withdrawal rate had never caused a retirement portfolio to fail within 30 years.
By Mark T ย ยทย Updated April 14, 2026
William Bengen: The Man Behind the Rule
Before turning to financial planning, William Bengen earned a degree in aeronautics from MIT. His scientific background shaped his approach: rather than relying on rules of thumb, he demanded data. When clients kept asking "how much can I safely spend in retirement?", Bengen decided to find a rigorous, historically grounded answer.
In 1994, he published "Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data" in the Journal of Financial Planning. The paper introduced what he called the SAFEMAX - the highest withdrawal rate that had never caused a 30-year portfolio to run dry across all historical periods in his dataset.
๐ Bengen's Research at a Glance
- Published: October 1994, Journal of Financial Planning
- Data range: US market returns, 1926โ1976
- Retirement horizon tested: 30 years
- Portfolio assumed: 50โ75% stocks, 25โ50% intermediate-term bonds
- Finding: 4% annual withdrawal (inflation-adjusted) never failed historically
The Trinity Study (1998): Independent Confirmation
Four years after Bengen, three finance professors at Trinity University - Philip Cooley, Carl Hubbard, and Daniel Walz - published a broader analysis in the AAII Journal. Their paper tested multiple asset allocations and withdrawal rates across historical 15-, 20-, 25-, and 30-year periods.
Key findings from the Trinity Study:
| Portfolio (Stocks/Bonds) | Withdrawal Rate | 30-Year Success Rate |
|---|---|---|
| 75% / 25% | 3% | 100% |
| 75% / 25% | 4% | 98% |
| 75% / 25% | 5% | 83% |
| 50% / 50% | 4% | 95% |
| 50% / 50% | 5% | 68% |
The Trinity Study popularized the term "safe withdrawal rate" and the 4% figure became the accepted shorthand for retirement planning across the industry.
What Bengen Later Said
Bengen continued refining his work over the following decades. Some notable updates:
- Small-cap boost: Adding small-cap stocks to the portfolio raised the SAFEMAX to approximately 4.5%, because small-cap equities have historically outperformed large-cap over long horizons.
- 4% is a floor, not a target: Bengen emphasized that 4% is a worst-case scenario from historical data. In most retirements, a 4% withdrawal leaves a significant portfolio remainder - often more than the starting value - because markets perform better than the worst-case assumption.
- Flexibility matters most: In later interviews, Bengen stressed that rigid adherence to any fixed rate is less important than willingness to adjust spending in response to poor market conditions.
The Research Landscape After Bengen
Several researchers have since extended - and challenged - Bengen's original conclusions:
| Study / Researcher | Year | Key Finding |
|---|---|---|
| Bengen (original) | 1994 | 4% SAFEMAX for 30-year US portfolios |
| Trinity Study (Cooley et al.) | 1998 | Confirmed ~95% success at 4% for 30 years |
| Pfau (Wade Pfau) | 2010โ2020s | Lower future returns may require 3โ3.5% for safety |
| Kitces (Michael Kitces) | 2012+ | Sequence-of-returns risk is the primary failure mode; dynamic spending improves outcomes |
| Bengen (updated) | 2020+ | 4.5% possible with small-cap exposure; 5% with favorable starting valuations |
Why the 4% Number Has Lasted 30 Years
Despite decades of academic scrutiny, the 4% figure has proven remarkably durable as a planning benchmark. It is not because it is always exactly right, but because it strikes a practical balance: conservative enough to survive the historically worst retirement start dates, simple enough to explain to any client, and flexible enough to adapt when circumstances change.
Bengen himself summed it up: "Four percent is not a magic number. It is a starting point for a conversation about how much risk a retiree is willing to bear."